In any organisation or group, decisions are critical to steering the future direction, driving success, and solving problems. However, not all decisions are made rationally or equitably. Often, hidden biases influence how decisions are made. This phenomenon is known as Decision-Making Bias, which refers to the unconscious tendencies and shortcuts that skew judgment and lead to less-than-ideal outcomes.
Watch
Listen to this article
Free DEI Research Briefings
Definition:
Decision-Making Bias is the tendency for individuals to make decisions based on preconceived notions, emotions, or mental shortcuts rather than on objective facts and logical reasoning. Biases are natural tendencies that can influence how we perceive information, weigh options, and ultimately decide between different courses of action. They occur at a subconscious level, often without people realising it, and can undermine fair and equitable decision-making.
In organisations that are committed to DEI, decision-making bias can limit diversity and hinder the goal of creating an inclusive environment. These biases can affect hiring practices, promotions, resource allocations, and everyday workplace interactions.
Impact:
In a diverse and inclusive environment, decisions should be made in ways that promote fairness and equity for everyone. Unfortunately, decision-making bias can prevent that from happening, leading to systemic inequities.
For example, confirmation bias in hiring may cause a manager to favor candidates who fit their own background or beliefs, even if other candidates are more qualified. Stereotyping can similarly affect promotion decisions, where individuals from underrepresented groups may be passed over due to unconscious biases about their abilities or fit within the organisation.
These biases can undermine DEI initiatives, fostering environments where certain groups are consistently marginalised. Over time, unchecked biases in decision-making erode trust, decrease employee morale, and reduce overall organisational performance.
Example:
Let’s say a company is hiring for a senior leadership position. The hiring team, subconsciously influenced by confirmation bias, leans toward candidates who have similar educational backgrounds and professional experiences as the current leadership. They assume these candidates will be a better “fit” with the company’s culture.
As a result, they may overlook more diverse candidates who bring different, but equally valuable, experiences and perspectives. This decision-making bias not only limits diversity but also stifles innovation, as the organisation misses out on the fresh ideas that diverse leadership could bring.
Conclusion:
Decision-Making Bias is a critical issue that can undermine efforts to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion in any organisation. It operates subtly, often unnoticed, but its effects can be far-reaching, contributing to systemic inequities and limiting opportunities for underrepresented groups. By recognising and addressing these biases, organisations can create more inclusive environments where decisions are made fairly, benefiting everyone involved.
Be impressively well informed
Get the very latest research intelligence briefings, video research briefings, infographics and more sent direct to you as they are published
Be the most impressively well-informed and up-to-date person around...